The Scale Was Never Telling the Truth
When I was younger, the scale ran everything.
That number was the whole story. If it dropped, I had a good day. A good week. A good life. Getting smaller was the goal, and I built my whole sense of myself around watching that number go down — as small as possible, as little as possible.
I look back now and I can see how unhealthy that was. Not my body. My body was fine. My mind was the unhealthy part.
I was chasing the wrong weight.
I think about that a lot now, because a few weeks ago I sat in a gym that runs entirely on that number. I was there to talk about coaching a few classes. And the whole time, I kept noticing this scale by the front door. Not tucked in a corner — right out where everyone walks in and out. The first thing you see, and the last.
While I was waiting, a woman finished her session, and before she could leave, the trainer walked her over to get weighed. Right in the open. Right in front of me. You see, yours is doing what you need to do. Keep working hard.
The approval was tied to the number. The number was the verdict.
And I sat there thinking about all the women walking through that door already feeling like they had to be better before they were even allowed in. Because that’s what a room like that does. A place that runs on urgency and proof will always make you feel behind — because feeling behind is what keeps you coming back to buy.
I don’t want to build anything on that.
Here’s the part I can’t move on
I’m not anti-scale. I want to be clear about that. I’m anti-chasing it.
Because here’s what I know now, as a woman in my 40s: if you chase that number down the old way — eat less, push harder, weigh in every Monday — you’re not just losing fat. You’re burning through muscle you can’t afford to lose at this age. So eventually you can’t hold it. And you don’t just land back where you started. You land worse — because now the muscle’s gone too.
I can’t set a woman up for that. I just can’t.
Losing weight just makes a number go down. Lifting weight makes everything else go up.
I keep coming back to that line because it’s the whole thing. When I stopped chasing smaller and started building strength, the number on the scale wasn’t the story anymore. My energy was. My focus. My back on a stiff morning. How I showed up for my kids, my partner, my clients. All of it went up — while the scale mostly stayed put.
The number isn’t the target. It’s the readout.
This is the part I want you to keep.
Build the body that feels good first. Get the consistency. Get to the place where it’s sustainable — where you’re actually living it, where it flows, where it’s doable. And then, if you want, step on the scale.
Because at that point, the number tells you something true. It’s a readout of where your body settles when you’re strong and steady — instead of the thing you’re bleeding yourself dry to drop.
That’s the difference. And it’s not that I don’t measure. I do. I just won’t measure your worth by that one number. I’ll look at your strength — what you can lift and carry and manage. Your photos over months. How your clothes fit. Whether you can keep coming back to it.
Those tell the truth. The Monday weigh-in as a verdict on whether you’re winning? I can’t get on that.
What it actually built
I’ll tell you where I am now, because I’m living the other side of it.
I rebuilt my strength with steps so small they looked like they didn’t count. One minute. Then five. Then ten. A version of the workout that wouldn’t have counted to the old me at all. And that’s the thing that kept building.
I’m body sculpting three times a week now — something I hadn’t been able to reach in years. Right now I’m actually carrying a little more than usual, on purpose, because I’m building muscle. And I’m at peace with the timeline, because I know what it’s building toward.
Not a smaller body. A bigger life.
That’s what showing up for one minute, then five, then ten actually gave me. And if you’ve spent years letting one number decide whether you’d had a good week — you’re not behind. You paused. There’s nothing to restart.
You just continue.
Come do it next to me.
My free Strong From the Core class is the door in — the foundational core and mobility work everything else is built on. Thursdays, 9 AM ET, on Google Meet. Come exactly as you are.
And when you’re ready for the group that keeps you coming back — short workouts for low-energy days, a weekly coaching call, camera always optional — the Show Up Method is there. No rush.
Strong. Steady. Sustainable.
— Gwen
